Prohibition Pizza wins High Springs Pizza Excellence Award

Prohibition Pizza in High Springs, Florida, won the Pizza Excellence Award from the Consumer Ratings Institute, a nod to its 4.7-star rating across 602 reviews and its standing in the local dining scene. The honor adds to a string of recent awards for the husband-and-wife-owned pizzeria.

Why it matters: - Prohibition Pizza’s latest award underscores how verified customer feedback can drive local restaurant recognition. - The honor highlights sustained diner approval in High Springs, where the pizzeria has become a familiar dining option. - The award adds momentum to Prohibition Pizza’s broader reputation in Florida’s pizza scene.

What happened: - The Consumer Ratings Institute named Prohibition Pizza the Pizza Excellence Award winner for High Springs. - The restaurant earned the recognition in September 2026. - Prohibition Pizza is an artisan New York-style pizzeria in High Springs, Florida, owned by Kelly and David Potter. - The pizzeria operates across from High Springs Brewing Company.

The details: - Prohibition Pizza holds a 4.7-star rating across 602 reviews. - The menu centers on New York-style pizza made with handmade dough fermented for 72 hours. - The restaurant uses daily-sliced, fresh, natural toppings. - The menu also includes oven-baked wings, salads and desserts. - Prohibition Pizza offers gluten-free options for guests with dietary restrictions. - The beverage list includes a curated wine selection and rotating craft beers from High Springs Brewing Company. - The restaurant serves locally inspired ingredients and emphasizes friendly, knowledgeable service. - A full menu and restaurant information are available online.

Between the lines: - The award reflects more than a single strong review score; it signals consistency across a large base of diners. - Prohibition Pizza has also built a track record beyond this honor. - The restaurant was voted Best Pizza in Florida in 2024, 2025 and 2026. - The Gainesville Sun named Prohibition Pizza Best Lunch in 2024. - The restaurant took second place for Best Cheese Pizza at the 2024 Galbani Cup.

What's next: - Prohibition Pizza will likely use the new award to reinforce its position with local diners and out-of-town visitors. - The restaurant continues serving High Springs and the surrounding area from its current location. - The Consumer Ratings Institute will keep using verified consumer feedback and service quality to identify businesses with strong trust signals.

The bottom line: - Prohibition Pizza’s award combines customer approval, consistent service and a growing trophy case into one clear message: the High Springs pizzeria is a local standout.